Starting out with a question: which part of the OT is Numbers
located in?
The Primary History
Hebrew
Bible Genesis–Deuteronomy Joshua–II
Kings
(Pentateuch) (Former
Prophets)
Noth Genesis–Numbers Deuteronomy–II
Kings
(Tetrateuch) (Deuteronomistic
History)
Wellhausen Genesis–Joshua Judges–II
Kings
(Hexateuch) (Collected
Traditions)
And
the rest of what has been called the Primary History of Israel is
called the Former Prophets by the Jews. That division wasn't good
enough for the critical Bible scholars in late 19th
and early 20th
century Germany. Noth, for example, moved Deuteronomy out of the
Pentateuch to leave only a Tetrateuch, while Wellhausen added one
book to the Pentateuch to make a Hexateuch.
Not to
be outdone by two Germans, I looked at the Primary History from a
structural point of view to see if any of these books were in close
parallel to one another, and came up with a
Hendecateuch: Structure
for the Primary History
IA.
Prelude (Gen. 1-11)
IB.
Covenant Relationship Defined (Gen. 12-50)
IC.
In the Wilderness: Part I (Exodus)
ID.
The Law (Leviticus)
IC'.
In the Wilderness: Part II (Numbers)
IB'.
Covenant Relationship Ratified (Deut. 1-30)
Center:
Deuteronomy 31-34
IIB.
Conquering the Land (Joshua)
IIC.
Possessing the Land: A Mixed History (Judges)
IID.
Transition of Leadership (I Samuel)
IIC'.
Possessing the Land: A Mixed History (II Samuel-I Kings)
IIB'.
Losing the Land (II Kings 1:1-23:25)
IA'.
Conclusion: Leaving the Promised Land (II Kings 23:26-25:30)
I obviously love these literary
arrangements found throughout the Bible for four reasons. In the
first place, they point out the inherent order God has put into
Scripture. I won't bore you with all the reasoning behind this
proposed organization, but note that the early history in Gen. 1-11
serves as a prelude to the formation of the Jewish nation while the
last chapters of Deuteronomy recap that history. The rest of Genesis
and Deuteronomy deal with the covenant relationship God established
with his chosen people; Exodus and Numbers can be read as a
continuous story of the journey from Egypt to Caanan and these two
books contain almost exactly the same number of words; and finally,
Leviticus stands apart from the rest of the Pentateuch as being
almost wholly a law book not a narrative.
And you can see that Noth was not
completely off-base in considering Deuteronomy with the following
history books since at least the last 5 chapters prepare us for the
events in the Promised Land.
The
Book of Numbers: Chuck
Swindoll's Table of Contents
Commands
(chs.1-9) Rebellion (chs.10-14) Punishment (chs.15-36)
Structural
Divisions
I.
Order (Chapters 1-10)
II.
Rebellion (Chapters 11-25)
I'.
New Order (Chapters 26-36)
That
brings us up to the Book of Numbers. Earlier, our regular Sunday school teacher presented
Swindoll's table of contents for this book, and it is a logical one.
God gives commands to the people but they constantly disobey so they
are punished. But often the events in the Bible are not given in a
logical order. And if you compare several commentaries on Numbers
with one another, you will find that they all have different ways of
dividing up the major sections in the book. That brings up the second
valuable thing about literary structures: they help determine the
intended divisions in the Scripture. The justification for the
three-fold division I propose in this slide is confirmed by the fact
that there is internal symmetry within each of the three groupings.
This contradicts the many scholars who don't see a lot of order in
the book.
Slide
“It presents us with a variety of genres...that seem to interrupt
each other and whose connections to each other are neither explicitly
stated nor easily seen.”
“...notoriously
defiant of structural analysis.”
“It is almost a
consensus that the Book of Numbers leaves much to be desired, and
that much is puzzling in the presentation of its material.”
“Many interpreters
complain that the book has no coherent organizational scheme or
outline.”
And these comments are from
evangelical scholars. I think they are missing the point because
they are looking for the wrong type of order in the Bible. Let's look
at the last third of the Book of Numbers, for example, since that is
where today's lesson is found.
The
Structure of Section III
A.
The Tribes Numbered (26:1-56)
B.
Levites Numbered (26:57-65)
C. Inheritance Laws for Daughters of Zelophehad
(27:1-11)
D.
End of Moses' Leadership (27:12-23)
E.
Final Legislation Before Crossing Jordan (ch. 28-29)
F. Women's Vows (ch. 30)
E'.
Final Narratives Before Crossing Jordan (ch. 31-32)
D'.
Summary of Moses' Leadership (33:1-49)
A'.
The Tribes' Inheritance (33:50-34:29)
B'.
Levites' Inheritance and Cities of Refuge (ch. 35)
C'. Inheritance Laws for Daughters of
Zelophehad (ch. 36)
You
can see why many scholars are rightly confused since each lettered
section represents a different story and the text seems to
haphazardly jump around from one subject to another and then repeat
itself. This sort of arrangement not only demonstrates that there is
perfect order in the text, but (and this is the third important thing
we can get from such an analysis) it also shows that sometimes the
appropriate context for understanding a portion of Scripture is
located
several
chapters later. Just look at our passage for today in bold. The last
half of chapter 27 should
really
be read in conjunction with chapter 33 since they both deal with the
same subject.
So all that introduces our
passage of the week, but I will warn you that I am
only going to briefly discuss it in order to concentrate on
some more important verses in that same chapter instead.
Moses
spoke to the LORD, saying, “Let the LORD, the God of the spirits of
all flesh, appoint someone over the congregation who shall go out
before them and come in before them, who shall lead them out and
bring them in, so that the congregation of the LORD may not be like
sheep without a shepherd.” Numbers 27:15-17
So the LORD said to Moses, “Take Joshua son of Nun, a man in whom
is the spirit, and lay your hand upon him; have him stand before
Eleazar the priest and all the congregation, and commission him in
their sight. You shall give him some of your authority, so that all
the congregation of the Israelites may obey.” Numbers 27:18-20
The cover of our weekly study guide has a picture of baton passing during a
relay race. And many races have been lost at this key point. I prefer
this picture. Notice that the
runner
receiving the baton is not standing still. He is already up to speed
by
the time of the hand-off.
Joshua,
for example, had almost 40 years working as Moses' assistant before
he was handed the
baton.
And the process didn't stop there. Look at the subsequent leaders
mentioned in the Book of Joshua and the overlap between them.
Leadership
in the Book of Joshua
Joshua,
son of Nun Eleazar Phinehas
1:1
2:1
2:23
6:6
---------------------------
14:1 14:1
17:4 17:4
19:49 -----
19:51 19:51
21:1 21:1
--------------------------
22:13 22:13
----- 22:30
22:31 22:31
22:32 22:32
Judges
20:28
It
is the very picture of a relay race. That is why mentoring of the
subsequent generation of leaders in the church is so important. At a
previous church where I led an adult Sunday school class, I began a
process of team teaching where different class members could try out
their hand at teaching. Many of them went on later to teach their own
classes at that church and other churches. And you probably know that
in our own church where various committees help conduct the
day-to-day business, there is a strong attempt to maintain a
continuity of both membership and leadership so that the committees
don't end up re-inventing the wheel each year. And
of course each of us is called to pass the Word on to others in our
circle of influence, especially our children and grandchildren.
As
important as this theme is in Numbers 27, there is another sometimes
neglected theme in that chapter that is just as important so I would
like to spend the rest of the class time on it. Let's look again at the structure of this
portion of Numbers.
The
Structure of Section III
A.
The Tribes Numbered (26:1-56)
B.
Levites Numbered (26:57-65)
C.
Inheritance Laws for Daughters of Zelophehad (27:1-11)
D.
End of Moses' Leadership (27:12-23)
E.
Final Legislation Before Crossing Jordan (ch. 28-29)
F.
Women's Vows (ch. 30)
E'.
Final Narratives Before Crossing Jordan (ch. 31-32)
D'.
Summary of Moses' Leadership (33:1-49)
A'.
The Tribes' Inheritance (33:50-34:29)
B'.
Levites' Inheritance and Cities of Refuge (ch. 35)
C'.
Inheritance Laws for Daughters of Zelophehad (ch. 36)
The
final way in which literary structures are important is in helping us
to identify the key points the author is stressing. In this case, the
structure actually points to three key passages of emphasis. In the
very center of these eleven chapters is a whole chapter devoted to
women's vows. From both the OT and NT we learn that vows made to God
are to be taken very seriously and once made, the person can't go
back on his vow. A problem arose in the patriarchal society of the
time when a woman living in her father's house or a married woman
made a vow (such as sacrificing
an
animal
on the altar) but her father or husband prevented her from carrying
it out. In response to this situation, God proclaimed a law excusing
such women from their vows under those conditions without coming
under any condemnation. However, any women living on their own were
expected to carry out their vows to God without exception just like
the men.
The
climaxes of the two parallel ABC series are also natural places where
important teachings are located. Both of these involve property
rights for women and the first is in Numbers 27, our chapter for
today.
Then the daughters of Zelophehad came forward...They stood before
Moses, Eleazar the priest, the leaders, and all the congregation, at
the entrance of the tent of meeting, and they said, “Our father
died in the wilderness...Why should the name of our father be taken
away from his clan because he had no son? Give to us a possession
among our father's brothers.” Numbers 27:1-4
Can you image the amount of nerve it took for
these five young, single women to go before all those people with
their request. But Moses doesn't just dismiss their complaints.
Moses
brought their case before the LORD. And the LORD spoke to Moses,
saying: The daughters of Zelophehad are right in what they are
saying; you shall indeed let them possess an inheritance among their
father's brothers and pass the inheritance of their father on to
them......It shall be for the Israelites a statute and
ordinance, as the LORD commanded Moses.
So it
actually established a legal precedent for the nation. That
isn't the end of the story, however. It is continued nine chapters
later when the girls' uncles complain to Moses:
“The
LORD commanded my lord to give the land for inheritance by lot to the
Israelites; and my lord was commanded by the LORD to give the
inheritance of our brother Zelophehad to his daughters. But if they
are married into another Israelite tribe, then their inheritance will
be taken from the inheritance of our ancestors and added to the
inheritance of the tribe into which they marry; so it will be taken
away from the allotted portion of our inheritance.” Numbers 36:2-3
Moses replies:
“This
is what the LORD commands concerning the daughters of Zelophehad,
'Let them marry whom
they think best;
only it must be into a clan of their father's tribe that they are
married, so that no inheritance of the Israelites shall be
transferred from one tribe to another.” Numbers 36:6-7
And the five sisters readily
agree to the compromise.
“...the character of the daughters is highlighted. They are
properly bold, in contrast to the cowardice of the ten spies. But
they are also properly obedient, willing to limit their choices and
options in service to the larger tribe...This boldness mixed with
obedience safeguards the inheritance of the social reality that the
land represents.” (David L. Stubbs, Numbers,
pp. 248-249)
This
brings up the issue
of
the Christian view of women today, a topic that has become rather hot
since last October. During
a
panel
discussion John MacArthur was asked what he thought of Beth Moore in
two words. His comment was “Go home.” Later a number of
evangelical leaders asked him to clarify his words, hoping that he
would be a little less confrontational. Unfortunately, MacArthur's
clarification ran as follows: “Women need to get themselves under
control and realize they are not to speak in a church.” Actually, some of the best comments I
have heard in class discussions have come from the women in the class.
Unfortunately, this controversy only adds
ammunition
to atheists who brand the Bible as being anti-women. So I thought it
might be useful to review some of the women highlighted in the Bible,
and do it in the form of a quiz.
Women
in the Old Testament
Who
was created in God's own image: man or woman? (Genesis 1:27)
Who
turned the LORD's wrath away from Moses? (Exodus 4:24-26) Zipporah
Who
was the third prophet listed in the Bible, after Abraham and Aaron?
Miriam
Who
was the first song composer named in the Bible? (Exodus 15:20-21)
Miriam (Selene knows)
Who
is the only person to be judge over Israel, a prophet, and a
co-general of the army” Deborah
Who
co-wrote the fifth chapter of Judges? Deborah
The
Book of Judges is especially known for stories in which women are
oppressed, as the Christian feminist Phyllis Trible points out in her
book Texts
of Terror.
But keep in mind that the purpose of Judges is to demonstrate in a
series of repeated cycles the constant failures of God's people to
live up to His commands. But in addition to these cycles, there is an
overall downward trend as one proceeds through Judges. That can be
illustrated in several ways, but the most obvious one is seen in the
way women are portrayed.
Decline
in the Time of Judges
Achsah
requests and gets more land from Caleb (1:11-15): another bold woman
asking for her fair rights and getting them.
Deborah
judges over Israel (chs. 4-5)
Jael
kills the commander of the Canaanite army by
driving a tent peg through his ear when he is sleeping. (chs. 4-5)
A
woman of Thebez kills the evil ruler Abimelech by dropping a
millstone on his head from the top of a tower
(9:50-54) These are all treated as heroes in the Bible who take
forceful action when necessary.
Jephthah's
daughter suffers because of her father's rash vow (11:34-40)
Samson's
wife becomes a pawn between Samson and the Philistines and is treated
poorly by both sides. (Judges
14-15)
A
Levite throws his concubine outdoors to a gang of Benjamites in order
to save himself, they rape her all night long, she dies, and then the
Levite cuts her body up
into 12 pieces (ch.19)
Benjamites
are given permission to kidnap the women of Shiloh and force them
into marriage (ch. 21)
Back
to the quiz: Which two books in the Bible have a woman as the main character?
Ruth and Esther
Which
book spends over half its time describing the inner thoughts of a
woman? Song of Solomon
Who
convinced David to pay attention to the nation's concerns when he was
depressed after Saul's death? Wise woman of Tekoa (2 Samuel 14:1-24)
Who
saved the people of the city of Abel from being destroyed? A wise
woman (2 Samuel 20) This was when David's forces were trying to
capture David's enemy Sheba who had fled there. She convinced David
to stop and the people of the city to hand over Sheba's head to them
instead.
Which
prophet
did
righteous King
Josiah consult? Huldah (2 Kings 22)
The
Book of Proverbs has been accused of dealing strictly with advice
given by a father to his son. But look at how it is organized. You
can see from the highlighted sections the equal prominence given here
to men and women. And the first half of Chapter 31 was even written
by a woman, Lemuel's mother.
The
Structure of Proverbs
I. Concerning Wisdom and
Wise Men (1:1-7)
II.
Warnings from a Father (1:8-3:36)
III. The Two Ways
(4:1-7:27)
IV.
Two Invitations (8:1-9:18)
V.
Four Books of Proverbs
IV'.
Skeptic Answered (30:1-6)
III'.
Agur’s Proverbs (30:7-33)
II'.
Warnings from a Mother (31:1-9)
I'.
Concerning Wisdom and the Wise Woman (31:10-31)
Women in the New Testament
How many women are listed in
Jesus' genealogy? 5 (Tamar, Rahab, Ruth, Bathsheba, Mary)
Who was the first Christian?
We will see if you were paying attention during
Hugh's last lesson. Mary, mother of Jesus (also according to
the cover story of Nov. CT).
Who, according to Luther,
preached the first Christian sermon? Elizabeth (Luke 1:39-45)
Who was commended by Jesus
for choosing the better portion? Mary, sister of Martha (Luke
10:38-42) because she wanted to learn
at the feet of Jesus. This was a rather revolutionary thing for Jesus
to say considering the conventional wisdom of the ancient rabbis at
the time.
“It is said,
‘Gather the men, women and children’—since the men come to
learn Torah and the women come to hear, why do the children come?”
Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah (1st cent. AD)
“Anyone who teaches his
daughter Torah teaches her sexual license.” Eliezer ben Hyrcanus
(1st-2nd cent. AD)
“Women’s wisdom is
solely in the spindle.” “The words of the Torah should be burned
rather than entrusted to women” Jerusalem Talmud (350-400 AD)
A year ago, an Israeli Supreme
Court
ruling ordered a halt at last to women entering the Western Wall
plaza being frisked for ritual items such as Torah scrolls. In
response, the ultra-Orthodox Party has proposed a bill classifying
the entire area as a holy site governed by Israel's rabbinic courts.
Who was
pointed out by Jesus as a superior example of giving? (Mark 12:42)
The widow and her mite
What female did Jesus
compare himself to? (Matt. 23:37) “Jerusalem, Jerusalem...How often
have I desired to gather your children together as a hen gathers her
brood under her wings, and you were not willing.”
Who stayed with Jesus when
he was on the cross? John, his mother Mary, her sister, Mary
Magdalene, Mary the mother of James and Joseph, the mother of the
sons of Zebedee, Salome
Who were the first witnesses
of the resurrection? Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James and
Joseph, Mary the wife of Clopas, Joanna, and Salome
Where did the
early church first meet? The house of Mary, the mother of Mark (Acts
12:12)
Were there women prophets in
the NT? (Anna in Luke 2:36; It was a fulfillment of Joel's words
quoted at Pentacost – Acts 2:18; Philip's four daughters in Acts
21:9; Paul says it was a regular occurrence in the early church – I
Cor. 11:4-5)
Who corrected the prominent
preacher Apollos' faulty theology? (Acts 18:26) Priscilla and Aquila
What titles does Paul give
Phoebe in Romans 16:2? A deacon in the church and a benefactor of
Paul
What is Junia's distinction?
(Romans 16:7)
She was a prominent apostle.
What is the church called in Revelation? The
bride of Christ (Rev. 19-22; Eph. 5:25-27)
One last question. Does
this quote remind you of any teaching in the NT? “Praise
God who has created me a human and not beast, a man and not a woman,
an Israelite and not a gentile, circumcised and not uncircumcised,
free and not slave.” Rabbi Judah (2nd
cent. AD)
Variations
of this prayer are still recited by Orthodox Jewish men today.
Some scholars have suggested that the Apostle Paul was
alluding to an earlier version of this blessing when he declared,
“There is no longer Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, neither male nor
female; for all of you are one in Christ Jesus.” Alternatively,
Rabbi Judah may have been reacting to Paul’s words to contradict
what Paul had said.
I think that
the final proof of Christians' view of women comes from the November
National Geographic issue of last year. They ranked 167 nations as
far as women's status is concerned. They used criteria such as equal
employment, access to education, freedom from violence, and strong
legal rights. It is no surprise that the top 30 nations almost all
had a strong Christian heritage while the bottom 60 were
overwhelmingly Muslim or Hindu countries.